The phones go in the drawer at 8:30 on Thursday nights. That was Paul's idea, not mine. He is the quiet one in this house, the man who can get through a whole dinner answering in single syllables, so when he suggested one night a week with no screens I said yes before he could take it back.
We have been married seventeen years. For the first few months of Thursdays we did fine. We sat on the back porch if the weather held, or at the kitchen table if it did not, and we talked about the kids, the roof, his mother's knee, the library budget I keep having to defend. Then around nine fifteen we would run out of words and start yawning at each other. Not fighting. Just empty.
So I started buying conversation decks. I have a drawer of them now, and the BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck is the one that stayed on the table. Some of the others were fine. Some were the kind of thing that makes you want to check your phone more, not less. One asked us to rate our communication on a scale of one to ten, which is exactly the sort of question that ends a Thursday night early in this house.
I bought it with some suspicion because of the word on the box. In our house intimacy usually means a conversation we should have had two weeks ago. But the cards turned out to be less about the bedroom and more about the parts of the week we had stopped narrating to each other.
Here is my bias, so you can weigh it. I am a school librarian and I like a structured prompt. Paul is an HVAC technician who spends all day talking to people and comes home with nothing left to say. A deck suits us in a way it might not suit a couple who are naturally chatty.
It is 170 conversation cards, cardstock, made for two players, and the box says 17 and up. I have used it enough now to be honest about the parts that work and the parts that made me squirm, and I have no interest in pretending otherwise.
Seventeen years in, I thought I knew how Paul would answer a question about the hardest season of his life. I was wrong by about a decade.
The deck that never went back in the drawer
170 cards across seven categories, made for two people at a kitchen table. Start with three cards and see where the evening goes.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →Here is how it actually works, because I know what some of these decks are like. You open the box, pull a card, read it out loud, and answer it. That is the whole thing. BestSelf Co. sorts the cards into seven categories, so you can pick the shallow end on a Thursday and save the deeper ones for a night when neither of you is tired.
The first card that got us was a simple one about what the other person could do to make the week lighter. I expected him to say something about dinner or the laundry. He said, 'A night where nobody needs anything from me.' I sat with that for a while. I had been treating his quiet as a personality trait instead of what it was, which was a man with nothing left in the tank by eight o'clock.
Not every card lands like that. Some of them are spicy in a way that feels strange on a Tuesday, with the dishwasher running and somebody's car alarm going off down the street. Some are the kind of question I would rather answer in writing, and one or two felt like homework I had not done. I skip those. The deck does not mind. BestSelf Co. printed more cards than any two people need in a month of Thursdays, so skipping three or four costs you nothing.
What changed for us was smaller than a card deck advertisement would have you believe. We did not have a breakthrough. We just stopped hitting that nine fifteen wall. Most weeks we get through three cards and then talk about something else entirely, which is the point. The cards are a starter, not a conversation.
I also want to be clear that this is not therapy and it did not fix anything that was actually broken. We were not in trouble. We were tired and a little bored, which is a different problem and a smaller one. If you are in real trouble, a box of cards is not the answer and I would not pretend otherwise.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
Start with three cards, not thirty. The first time we opened the box we tried to work through a whole category in one sitting, and by the end we were both answering in that polite voice people use at the DMV. Three is enough. Put the rest away and leave something for next week.
Skip anything that feels like a trap. If a card makes your stomach drop before you have read the second half, put it back and tell your partner why. Half the value in the BestSelf Co. deck is the conversation about which cards you are both avoiding. Also, put the phones somewhere you would have to stand up to reach. A drawer across the room works better than a face down phone on the table, and yes, I know that from experience.
One box, two people, one Thursday night
If you have hit that nine fifteen wall in your own house, this is the least complicated way I know past it. It will not fix anything. It will give you something to say.
Amazon See the BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck on Amazon →