Three years ago Paul and I worked out that we had become very good roommates. We split the lawn, we knew each other's schedules down to the minute, and by nine o'clock most nights we had nothing left to say that was not logistics. That is how the Thursday no-phones night started in our house. It is also how I ended up buying two conversation decks, spreading both of them across the kitchen table, and running them on alternating weeks for about two months.
Here is the short answer. If you have been with the same person for years and you want prompts that assume a shared past, get the BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck. If you want a deck that also works with your sister, your coworkers, and the couple you just met at a backyard party, get We're Not Really Strangers. Both are cardstock cards in a box, both are made for two players at a time, and neither one needs an app. They are built for different tables, and the table most long-term couples sit at is the one the BestSelf Co. deck was built for.
| BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck | We're Not Really Strangers | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is built for | Two people with years of shared history and unfinished conversations | Any two people, including strangers and brand new couples |
| How much is in the box | 170 cards you can jump around in from night one | A tighter deck arranged in three levels with wildcards mixed in |
| Depth for a long relationship | Cards assume you have a past together, so the answers get specific | Broad enough to open with a stranger, which keeps the deep end general |
| Easing in a reluctant partner | Opens at a real question, no warm-up round, which some people find steep | Level one is deliberately light and gets a skeptic talking first |
| Playing with anyone but your partner | Written for a couple and it reads that way at a group table | Works with friends, siblings, and people you barely know |
| Repeat play | Enough prompts to shuffle and land somewhere new months later | Once a question has been answered, its pull is mostly spent |
| Format | Cardstock cards in a box, manual use, nothing to charge | Cardstock cards in a box, nothing to charge |
Two rows in that table are why the other deck is still in my house. I did not expect to concede the group setting, and I did not expect the warm-up level to matter as much as it did. Those two things are the whole case for We're Not Really Strangers, and I will get to them properly below.
How I Tested Both Decks
I am not a relationship researcher. I am a middle school librarian in Columbus, Ohio, married to an HVAC technician named Paul for 17 years. What I had going for this test was a kitchen table, a small back porch, two teenagers who go to bed at a reasonable hour, and a standing Thursday night when both phones stay in a drawer until morning.
We gave each deck its own Thursday, then swapped and ran them both again on a Saturday when Paul's brother and his wife came over. That second setting told me more than the first one did. One deck got better with four people at the table. The other went flat and a little awkward, and I put it away before the dessert dishes were cleared.
My test for a prompt is simple. It is good if it produces a sentence neither of us has said out loud before. Not a confession, not a fight, just something new. A deck that lands two or three of those in an evening is earning its space on the shelf. A deck that lands none is a coaster with better packaging.
I should also say what I am not comparing. I did not test either deck against a therapist, a weekend away, or any of the phone versions people recommend. I am comparing two boxes of cards on one kitchen table, over one stretch of weeks, in one house. That is a small sample. It is also the sample most people actually have.
What Is Actually in the BestSelf Co. Box
There are 170 cards in the BestSelf Co. box, grouped by topic, and the listing puts the recommended age at 17 and up. The cards are cardstock, which held up fine through two months of being shuffled, dropped, and waved around during an argument about who was going to take the recycling out. The box is a box. It is not a design object, but it closes, and that is all I ask of a thing that lives on a counter.
The topic groupings are the part I underrated. The categories run across love, life, dreams and desires, and they are not all the same weight. Some nights we wanted the lighter end of love and life. Some nights we wanted the dreams and desires cards, which are harder and take longer to answer. Because the cards are sorted by topic rather than sequenced, we could pick the mood instead of working through the box in order and landing on a heavy card at the wrong moment.
The deck is built for two players, which sounds limiting until you notice that this is the entire design. There is no turn order to manage and no host. One of us pulls a card, reads it out, and we both answer. On a Thursday that takes twenty minutes or an hour depending on where the card lands, and there is no wrong place to stop.
Where the BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck Wins
The prompts assume you have history. That sounds obvious until you sit with a deck whose questions cannot assume anything. We're Not Really Strangers has to work for two people who met an hour ago, so its cards cannot lean on seventeen years of shared Tuesdays, a house, two kids, and the year Paul's job moved him to second shift. The BestSelf Co. deck can lean on all of it, and the answers get specific in a way a general deck never reaches. Several cards asked us to look at the relationship itself, and Paul answered one of them in a way I have thought about since.
Volume is the second thing. There are 170 prompts, which means we can come back in March and land somewhere we have not been. A deck with forty cards runs out. This one has enough that we have not repeated a question yet, and we have not been careful about it. There is also no sequence to follow and no level to unlock, which matters to us. We have been doing this long enough that a warm-up round feels like being handled.
It does not coddle you, and for this couple that is a feature. Paul would rather be asked a hard question straight than be eased into it for twenty minutes, and the deck just asks. The listing puts the recommended age at 17 and up, which matches what is in the box. It carries a 4.6 from more than 10,000 ratings, and the manufacturer says more than 200,000 couples have used it. What I can vouch for is narrower and more useful: at my table, on an ordinary Thursday, it produced new sentences.
Seventeen years in, a card still got a sentence out of Paul that I had never heard before. That is the whole review.
Where We're Not Really Strangers Wins
The four-person Saturday. This is not close. That deck is organized into three levels, and the first one is deliberately light, which means it plays beautifully with a brother-in-law who did not ask to be there. Nobody has to reveal anything before they are ready, and the table stays easy. When we ran the BestSelf Co. deck with four people, the questions kept assuming a couple's private context, and our two guests spent the evening watching us instead of playing.
The on-ramp is real, and I want to be fair about it. Paul is the quieter one in this marriage, and he will tell you himself that a soft first question is what gets him talking. The three-level structure does that work without announcing that it is doing work. My deck opens at a real question, and on a tired weeknight that can be too steep a first step for somebody who was not in the mood to begin with.
It also travels. It was written for strangers and new connections, so it works with a new couple, a group of friends, a sibling you see twice a year. I have put it in front of near strangers at a cookout and it went fine. I would not put the other one in front of that table. It is the more flexible object, and if your life has more mixed company in it than quiet Thursdays, that flexibility is most of what you are buying.
For the couple who already has seventeen years to talk about
170 cards for two players, cardstock in a box, nothing to charge and nothing to install. If your evenings have slid into logistics and television, this is where I would start.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →The Part Neither Deck Fixes
A card cannot make a quiet person talkative, and it cannot make a busy person sit down. On our third week with the decks we quit halfway through and watched two episodes of something forgettable instead. That was not the deck's fault. It was a week that had been long for both of us, and no stack of cardstock was going to fix it.
What the deck does is remove the excuse. The box sits on the counter and one of us picks it up. If you are looking for something that repairs a marriage, this is cardstock and it will not do that. If you are looking for something that gets two tired people past the weather and the kids' schedules and into an actual conversation, it does that reliably. The distance between those two claims is the honest version of this review.
There is also the matter of who answers first. In our house it is always me, which means my answers set the temperature for his. If you are the talker in your relationship, let your partner draw and answer first at least once, and you will find out what the deck can actually do.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck if you have been together long enough that the small talk ran out years ago, if you can both survive one uncomfortable question without it turning into a fight, and if your kids are old enough to leave you alone for an hour. Respect the 17 and up guidance. If you are three months into a relationship, put it on a list and come back to it later.
Buy We're Not Really Strangers if your table usually has more than two people at it, if you want something you can also play with friends, or if your partner needs a gentle first step before anything real. It is the better icebreaker. It is the weaker tool for a couple who broke the ice seventeen years ago and would like to find it again.
If you are buying as a gift, the split holds. A long-married couple gets the BestSelf Co. deck. A couple in their first year, or a friend who hosts a lot of dinners, gets the other one. And if you are not sure which couple you are looking at, read the table at the top of this page again, because the answer is in the row about who it is built for.
For the couple who has run out of new sentences
170 prompts, two players, 17 and up. Ours has lived on the kitchen counter for months, and it is still the deck we reach for on a Thursday.
Amazon See the BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck on Amazon →