Paul and I have been married for seventeen years, and last winter we hit a stretch where our longest conversation of the day was about the thermostat. Not a fight. Nothing dramatic. Just two people running a house and a schedule together and calling that a marriage. I am a middle school librarian in Columbus, so I spend all day around people who talk for a living, and I still could not come up with one interesting question for my own husband at nine o'clock at night.

What we tried first did not work. A show we both half watched. A Saturday dinner out that cost too much and ended by nine fifteen with both of us tired. I bought a paperback book of conversation starters two years ago and it is still on the shelf with a receipt marking page four. What finally worked was low tech and a little awkward: a box of conversation cards on the kitchen table and a standing Thursday night with the phones left in the other room. The deck we have used for over a year now is the Intimacy Deck from BestSelf Co., 170 conversation cards made for two people who already know each other well and have quietly run out of things to ask.

I am not going to tell you a card deck fixed anything. It did not fix the scheduling or the division of chores or the fact that Paul and I are both better at managing a household than at talking to each other. What it did was give us somewhere to start. The five steps below are how we actually use it, adjusted after a year of Thursday nights that went well and a handful that went sideways.

One box on the counter beats another night of the thermostat talk

The BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck holds 170 conversation cards across seven curated topic categories, built for two players and recommended for ages 17 and up. You do not need a plan for your marriage. You need a Thursday.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

Step 1: Pick the night before you pick the questions

The mistake we made for years was waiting for a good conversation to happen on its own. It does not. Thursday does. Pick a night that is boring on purpose, because a boring night has room in it, and put it on the calendar the way you would a dentist appointment. Ours is Thursday, which started a few years back when we had gone about four months feeling like roommates with a shared mortgage. When we restarted it, I wrote it in pen on the paper calendar that hangs by the fridge and told the kids it was a thing now. That sounds silly. It worked. A night that lives only in your head gets cancelled the first time somebody is tired, and somebody is always tired. A night written in pen on the fridge calendar has to be argued with first, and in a year neither of us has bothered.

Two things matter more than which night you choose. It is the same night every week, and it is short. Thirty to forty minutes is plenty. The kids go to bed, the phones go face down in the other room, and we sit at the kitchen table, or out on the back porch if the weather is decent. Our first four Thursdays I set the stove timer for thirty minutes because I did not trust the two of us to last that long, and we both kept glancing at it like it owed us something. We dropped the timer in March. If the conversation runs long now, fine, but nobody has to survive a two hour summit on a weeknight.

Leave the box out where you can see it. That sounds trivial and it is not. A deck in a drawer is a deck you never open, and that has been true of every game, journal and piece of exercise equipment in this house. Ours sits on the end of the kitchen counter next to the napkins, which is the least romantic spot in the room and the reason we remember it. The one time I put it away in the cabinet above the microwave, we skipped two weeks running and did not notice until the third.

Close view of a person in their forties holding a card drawn from a card deck while their partner listens from across the table

Step 2: Start in the shallow end of the deck

The Intimacy Deck is organized into seven curated topic categories, and they are not all the same temperature. The first night we sat down, I shuffled and pulled a card from the middle, and it landed on a question about what we each want more of in the relationship. That is a good card. It is not a first night card, when two people are sitting up straight and being polite to each other. Paul answered it in about nine words, then looked at the ceiling for a while, and I sat there thinking this whole idea was about to become one more thing we tried for a week.

So start with the categories that ask about memories, preferences and what the other person is looking forward to. Those are warm ups, and they do the real work of getting two quiet people talking. Ten minutes of easy cards buys you a much better conversation later than opening with the heavy material ever will. By the time we reach the harder categories, we have been talking for twenty minutes, our shoulders have come down, and the stiff part of the evening is over. The reverse is also true. On the nights we started cold with the heavier deck, we were done in fifteen minutes and both of us were in a worse mood than when we sat down.

One more thing about the categories. If you are the one who always picks the card, stop. Hand the deck to your partner every other week. Paul deals differently than I do, and the nights he deals go in directions I would never have chosen, which is most of the point of doing this with another person. He also shuffles better than I do, which I will admit here and deny if asked.

Step 3: Answer the card yourself first, and go one sentence longer than feels natural

Paul is quieter than I am. If I hand him a card and then wait, I get a two word answer and a shrug, and then I get irritated about a shrug that was never meant to be irritating. So I go first. I read the card out loud, I answer it honestly, and then I add one more sentence than I normally would.

That extra sentence is usually where the real answer lives. Saying I am proud of how we handled my mother's move is a fine answer. Saying I am proud of how we handled my mother's move, and I am still tired of being the one who makes the phone calls, is a conversation. The second version is the one that gets us somewhere, and it only comes out when one of us goes first and goes long.

The other half of this step is shutting up. When Paul does answer at length, my job is to let him finish and then ask one follow up question. Not two. Not a cross examination. One question, then silence, then whatever he says next. I am bad at this. I have gotten better at it, mostly because he now finishes his sentences instead of trailing off, and that is its own reward.

Two people in their forties sitting in chairs on a small back porch in the early evening, one leaning back and listening

Step 4: Build in a pass and keep the pass boring

There are cards in this deck I will not answer on a weeknight, and a couple I will not answer at all. That is allowed, and the evening is better for it. The pass only works if it is boring, though. Say the word pass, put the card at the bottom of the deck, take the next one, and move on.

No explaining. No we will come back to that. No face. The moment a pass turns into a conversation about why someone passed, you have taught each other that honesty costs something, and the next honest answer comes out a little quieter. Paul has passed maybe six times in a year. I have passed twice, both on the same category, and neither of us could tell you now which cards they were. That forgetting is the whole point. If I could still name the card I passed on, I would be carrying it around, and so would he.

Step 5: End on one small thing you will actually do

The last five minutes are the part that made this stick for us. Before we put the deck away, each of us names one small thing from the conversation that turns into an action that week. Small is the entire point. Not we should take a trip. More like I will look up that campground you mentioned and text you two options by Sunday.

Then the other person does not ask about it again. It either happens or it does not, and if it does not, that is information too, delivered without a fight. A year in, this is the piece I would keep if I had to throw out everything else. It turns a pleasant evening into a small change, and small changes are the only kind that have ever survived in our house.

A year in, we still keep Thursday. That is longer than any hobby the two of us have ever started together.

What Else Helps

Keep the deck in its place. It is a door, not the room. If you have something genuinely hard to work through, a marriage counselor or a long walk without cards is a better tool, and a card game that wanders into a real crisis stops being fun fast. The BestSelf Co. deck is for the ordinary, unglamorous work of staying interested in someone you see every day.

If sitting across a table feels like a job interview, take the cards in the car or on a walk. Something about not making eye contact unlocks people, Paul especially. We have worked through half a deck on a drive to Cincinnati and gotten further than three dinners out ever managed, mostly because neither of us could escape to the kitchen, and the questions kept coming with the highway signs.

Also give the room a chance. Our kitchen table in February, with a lamp on and the dishes done, is a better setting than the couch. The couch has a television near it and a television wins every argument about where to put your attention. The one time we tried a Thursday in the living room with the game on mute, we got through four cards and then gave up and watched the second half.

And do not do it every night. Once a week is plenty. Scarcity is what keeps the questions from turning into homework, and homework is the fastest way to make two people resent a box of cards. When Thursday is over, put the deck back on the counter and go watch something with a laugh track.

Last thing. If your partner is skeptical, do not sell it. Paul agreed to one Thursday and reserved the right to hate it. He did not hate it. He asked for it again the following week, which from him is a rave review.

Thursday is coming either way. You might as well have something to ask.

The BestSelf Co. Intimacy Deck. 170 cards, seven curated topic categories, two players, ages 17 and up. Start in the shallow end, pass when you need to, and end with one small thing you will actually do.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →