I know my husband's shoe size, his blood pressure number, and exactly how he takes his coffee. What I could not tell you, until a few Thursdays ago, is what he thinks about when he cannot sleep.
I am Renee Ashworth. Paul and I have been married for seventeen years. He fixes heating systems, I run a middle school library in Columbus, and a few years back we started a Thursday no phones night because we had begun to feel like two people splitting a mortgage instead of two people who liked each other. It worked for a while. Then it turned into watching television in the same room without saying much.
So I ordered WE'RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS Couples Edition. It is a deck of conversation cards for two players, ages 15 and up, and the box says about 15 minutes to play. That last number is the reason it sits on our coffee table instead of the drawer where the other games go to die.
Our conversation had narrowed to logistics. Who is driving our son to practice. Did you pay the water bill. Is our daughter's project finished. We were running a household well and skipping each other in the process. I wanted a way to ask Paul something he had not already answered a hundred times, and I wanted it to take less time than one episode of anything.
The first Thursday did not go well. I read a card out loud, Paul gave me a four word answer, and then he looked at the clock. I put the deck away and we watched television. I am telling you that because most reviews of a conversation game skip the part where it lands wrong the first time.
Seventeen years in, and I still had a question I had never thought to ask him. That was the part that stung.
If your Thursday nights have gone quiet, start with one card
Two players. About fifteen minutes. The deck that got Paul talking about something other than the thermostat.
Amazon See the deck on Amazon →The second Thursday I changed one thing. I did not read the card to him. I handed it over and let him read it to me. Paul is quieter than I am, and putting the card in his hand gave him the question instead of the answer. He read it, went quiet for a second, and then talked for six minutes about his father's shop and the smell of sawdust in it. We have been married since 2009 and I had never heard that story told that way.
The cards themselves are thick cardstock, which sounds like a small detail until you have pulled a thin deck out of a drawer and found it fused into one brick. The WE'RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS deck has held up through a summer on the porch and a coffee ring or two.
Some cards are silly and let the air out of the room. Some ask you to say out loud something you have been thinking quietly for years. There is no board, nothing to score, and nobody wins, which matters in a house where one of us gets competitive about Monopoly and ruins a Sunday afternoon. It is built for exactly two players, which sounds limiting until you remember that the two of you are the whole point. No teams, no waiting for a turn, no fourth person needed to keep the energy up.
The fifteen minutes on the box is honest, and we usually stop before that. Four cards, then the deck goes back in the box, and it still counts as a real conversation. That is what keeps it in rotation at our house. Anything that asks for an hour gets played twice a year and then lives in the closet. A friend asked me whether it feels like homework. Some nights it does. There was a Thursday in July when we got through one card, admitted we were too tired to be interesting, and ate ice cream on the porch instead. The deck was still on the table the next week.
One note on the age range. The box says 15 and up, and our fourteen year old daughter asked about it when she saw it on the table. We told her it is a grown up deck and put it back on the shelf. It stays there until the kids are in bed.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
Here is what I would say, and I would say it before you order anything. This deck does not fix a marriage. It will not make a quiet man loud, and it will not carry two people who have stopped liking each other. What it does is put a question in front of you that you would not have thought to ask on a Tuesday, and it gives you permission to answer it out loud without the conversation turning into an argument about the dishwasher.
If you want a night of entertainment, buy a different game. WE'RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS is not that and does not pretend to be. If you want to hear your husband talk about something other than the thermostat and the driveway, this is the simplest way I know to make that happen.
We still do the no phones rule on Thursdays. Now there is a deck on the table next to the salt shaker, and some weeks we get through two cards and some weeks eight. Paul asked me something last month that I am still turning over. Seventeen years, and there is more in there than I assumed.
Put it on the coffee table and read one card out loud
The WE'RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS Couples Edition deck. Two players, ages 15 and up, about fifteen minutes a round. Start with the card you would least want to answer yourself.
Amazon See it on Amazon →